XML Feed for RxPG News   Add RxPG News Headlines to My Yahoo!   Javascript Syndication for RxPG News

Research Health World General
 
  Home
 
 Latest Research
 Cancer
 Psychiatry
 Genetics
 Surgery
 Aging
 Ophthalmology
 Gynaecology
 Neurosciences
 Pharmacology
 Cardiology
 Obstetrics
 Infectious Diseases
 Respiratory Medicine
 Pathology
 Endocrinology
 Immunology
 Nephrology
 Gastroenterology
 Biotechnology
 Radiology
 Dermatology
 Microbiology
 Haematology
 Dental
 ENT
 Environment
 Embryology
 Orthopedics
 Metabolism
 Anaethesia
 Paediatrics
 Public Health
 Urology
 Musculoskeletal
 Clinical Trials
 Physiology
 Biochemistry
 Cytology
 Traumatology
 Rheumatology
 
 Medical News
 Health
 Opinion
 Healthcare
 Professionals
 Launch
 Awards & Prizes
 
 Careers
 Medical
 Nursing
 Dental
 
 Special Topics
 Euthanasia
 Ethics
 Evolution
 Odd Medical News
 Feature
 
 World News
 Tsunami
 Epidemics
 Climate
 Business
 
 India
Search

Last Updated: Nov 18, 2006 - 12:32:53 PM

Ethics Channel
subscribe to Ethics newsletter

Special Topics : Ethics

   DISCUSS   |   EMAIL   |   PRINT
Doctor-assisted suicide wouldn't undermine patient trust - Research
Dec 5, 2005 - 4:08:00 AM, Reviewed by: Dr.

"Overall, three times as many people disagree as agree that legalizing physician-assisted death would cause them to trust their personal doctors less,"

 
There is little evidence to support the argument that legalizing physician-assisted death would reduce patients' trust in their doctors, according to a researcher from Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center and colleagues.

"Overall, three times as many people disagree as agree that legalizing physician-assisted death would cause them to trust their personal doctors less," said Mark Hall, J.D., professor of public health sciences at Wake Forest Baptist and Fred D. and Elizabeth L. Turnage Professor of Law at Wake Forest University.

Hall and colleagues designed a random telephone survey of 1,117 adults in the United States to measure attitudes about physician aid in dying. The results are reported in the current issue of the Journal of Medical Ethics.

Survey participants were asked to use a five-point scale to state their agreement or disagreement with this statement: "Assume for the purpose of this question that euthanasia were legal. If doctors were allowed to help patients die, you would trust your doctor less." The question did not distinguish between physician-assisted suicide, where the physician helps a patient take his or her own life, and euthanasia, where the physician directly administers the lethal dosage, because prior studies found that attitudes are essentially the same for both.

A majority (58 percent) of participants disagreed with the statement. Only 20 percent said that legalizing euthanasia would cause them to trust their personal physician less. These attitudes were the same in men and women.

Older adults (age 65 or older) and blacks were more likely than other groups to say physician aid in dying would lower trust, but this view was still in the minority. Only 27 percent of older participants and 32 percent of blacks said euthanasia would lower trust.

"Despite the widespread concern that legalizing physician-assisted death would seriously threaten or undermine trust in physicians, the weight of the evidence in the United Sates is to the contrary, although views vary significantly," said Hall.

The debate over physician-assisted death often includes assertions about the impact on patient trust, yet there has been little data on the subject, Hall said. There are two prior studies on the topic, but they were confined to residents of Massachusetts and Iowa, and they were generally consistent with the findings from this study.

Hall said that public policy advocates often overstate their case when they argue that particular legal or ethical rules are necessary to support trust. Even the U.S. Supreme Court has noted that physician-assisted suicide could "undermine the trust that is essential to the doctor-patient relationship by blurring the time-honored line between healing and harming."

Hall said that evidence for this argument is weak.

"Our study shows that only about 20 percent of people believe they would trust their physician less if euthanasia were legalized," he said. "The empirical support is weak for those who confidently assert that legalizing physician-assisted death would undermine trust in physicians for most people in the United States."

The researchers said, however, that the research doesn't necessarily support the opposing side, either.

"We should not be cavalier about potential threats to trust because, once it is lost, it is far harder to rebuild than to sustain," write the authors. Banning physician-assisted suicide or euthanasia could thus still be justified as a measure to avoid any diminution in trust."
 

- The results are reported in the current issue of the Journal of Medical Ethic
 

www.wfubmc.edu

 
Subscribe to Ethics Newsletter
E-mail Address:

 

Hall's co-researchers are Felicia Trachtenberg, Ph.D., from the New England Research Institutes and Elizabeth Dugan, Ph.D., from the University of Massachusetts Medical School. The research was funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center is an academic health system comprised of North Carolina Baptist Hospital and Wake Forest University Health Sciences, which operates the university's School of Medicine. The system comprises 1,187 acute care, psychiatric, rehabilitation and long-term care beds and is consistently ranked as one of "America's Best Hospitals" by U.S. News & World Report.



Related Ethics News

Waiting For Trial Results Sometimes Unethical
NHGRI Funds Assessment of Public Attitudes About Population-Based Studies on Genes and Environment
Physicians More Likely To Disclose Medical Errors That Would Be Apparent To The Patient
Doctors inadvertently help terminally ill patients to die sooner
Intellectual property law and the protection of traditional knowledge
Conscientious objection in medicine should not be tolerated
Yale guidelines for physician interactions with pharmaceutical industry
Current interpretation of the data protection law is hampering epidemiological research
Massachusetts state can pull plug on comatose 11-year-old girl
Facial Transplants - Are they justified?


For any corrections of factual information, to contact the editors or to send any medical news or health news press releases, use feedback form

Top of Page

 

© Copyright 2004 onwards by RxPG Medical Solutions Private Limited
Contact Us