RxPG News XML Feed for RxPG News   Add RxPG News Headlines to My Yahoo!  

Medical Research Health Special Topics World
 
  Home
 
 Careers 
 Dental
 Medical
 Nursing
 
 Latest Research 
 Aging
 Anaethesia
 Biochemistry
 Biotechnology
 Cancer
 Cardiology
 Clinical Trials
 Cytology
 Dental
 Dermatology
 Embryology
 Endocrinology
 ENT
 Environment
 Gastroenterology
 Genetics
 Gynaecology
 Haematology
 Immunology
 Infectious Diseases
 Metabolism
 Microbiology
 Musculoskeletal
 Nephrology
 Neurosciences
 Obstetrics
 Ophthalmology
 Orthopedics
 Paediatrics
 Pathology
 Pharmacology
 Physiology
 Psychiatry
 Public Health
 Radiology
 Rheumatology
 Surgery
 Urology
 Alternative Medicine
 Medicine
 Epidemiology
 Sports Medicine
 Toxicology
 
 Medical News 
 Awards & Prizes
 Epidemics
 Health
 Healthcare
 Launch
 Opinion
 Professionals
 
 Special Topics 
 Ethics
 Euthanasia
 Evolution
 Feature
 Odd Medical News
 Climate
  India Business
  India Culture
  India Diaspora
  India Education
  India Entertainment
  India Features
  India Lifestyle
  India Politics
  India Sci-Tech
  India Sports
  India Travel
 
 DocIndia 
 Reservation Issue
 Overseas Indian Doctor

Last Updated: May 17, 2007 - 8:46:52 AM
News Report
India Education Channel

subscribe to India Education newsletter
India Education

   EMAIL   |   PRINT
Will IITs remain islands of excellence?
Mar 11, 2007 - 11:48:31 AM
It is true that some of these cannot be as objective as JEE test scores. But by adopting more representative admission standards - though less objective - IITs may be able to get students with potential for creativity and research. This may reduce the importance of coaching factories.

Article options
 Email to a Friend
 Printer friendly version
 India Education channel RSS
 More India Education news
[RxPG] At a recent event organized at the Indian Institute of Technology - in Chennai, Tata Steel managing director B. Muthuraman expressed disenchantment with its graduates. 'We are not likely to recruit them any longer,' he said, adding his company preferred students from other colleges, who, though less endowed, were more amenable to company training. IIT guys tend to think too much of themselves.

Reality is that brand IIT thrives on its past reputation.

The Tata Steel chief, recalling his recent interaction with some final-year students of IIT Chennai, observed they could not even name the authors of the subject books they were supposed to have studied. He later found out that the students were able to clear the tests without having to read books. He was in for further shock on discovering that their teachers were no more knowledgeable about the subjects they were supposed to teach.

His observations came as a deflating revelation to the IIT alumni that had come for the Ruby Union from all around the world. Muthuraman and the Tata Steel were not alone in their perception of today's IIT graduates. Some other companies are equally disinterested in recruiting from IITs. This should prove writing on the wall for IIT educationists and policy-makers at the ministry.

A reason for this sorry state is in the method students adopt to get admitted to IITs. On the one hand IIT admissions have been praised for being free from corruption and undue interference. No one, however well connected, can gain entry unless he/she manages to get a high enough rank in the joint entrance examination -.

Infosys mentor N.R. Narayana Murthy told a TV show host in the US that his son had to consider offers from Harvard, Wharton etc. as he couldn't get into IIT. This one statement made much mileage for IITs reputation the world over. Surveys by foreign universities ranked IITs quite high. And yet a section of corporate India is sceptical of IIT graduates.

Why? Because most of them resort to coaching shops to gain entry into IIT. An IIT review committee report in 2004 had questioned the calibre of students selected on the basis of an extremely tough entrance examination conducted by IIT joint Entrance Examination -.

Needlessly, tough standards set by the examining board drive students to coaching shops, to secure high ranks in JEE and, once in IIT, these students tend to ignore the rigors of higher education. It is reckoned 95 percent of the candidates seeking admission into IITs go through coaching shops, paying high fees.

The amount of money spent by IIT aspirants attending the coaching factories is about Rs.20 billion - per year - four times the government's annual budgetary allocation for the IITs. About 160,000 students take JEEs and 3,500 are admitted to the seven IITs.

The distorted impact of assembly line coaching taken by candidates is indicated by the percentage of students admitted to IITs from different states in southern India. During a recent year under review, 979 candidates from the south zone secured admission. Of them, 769 were from Andhra Pradesh, while Tamil Nadu accounted for 94 successful candidates, Karnataka, 84, and Kerala, for no more than 32 candidates.

Andhra Pradesh may well be producing bright IIT entrants, but those from the other three states can't be that poor. Mushrooming of IIT tutorials and coaching factories in Hyderabad may have much to do with the JEE results. In the north zone, Rajasthan is an unlikely state that is reported to have been doing well sending a high proportion of students to IITs like Andhra Pradesh. Kota in Rajasthan has a reputation for offering pressure-cooker coaching for IIT hopefuls.

In the beginning, IITs used to give admission to high-ranking students from each state. When an admission test was first introduced there were no coaching classes. However, during the past 21 years, coaching for IIT admission has become the norm. Candidates who are into IIT coaching right from their final schooling years have put IIT tuition before their studies. The all-important entrance tests system has resulted in producing IIT aspirants with a one-track mindset. By the time they start studies at IITs, they feel burnt out. But it doesn't show up, as failure rate in IITs is minimal. Getting admission into IITs is tough, but not passing out of them.

These students are good at the technique of answering questions, without grasping the underlying concepts. IIT professors have written many papers criticizing the present competitive testing procedure. Its review committee has suggested a research panel to come up with an alternative system. But there does not appear to be enough momentum to bring about the much-needed changes.

Instead of giving ranks purely on the basis of JEE performance, IITs can adapt multiple criteria, giving a weighted score. Some of the criteria are JEE test scores, some marks for showing leadership qualities, marks for demonstrating social concern and talents in sports, music, arts, etc.

It is true that some of these cannot be as objective as JEE test scores. But by adopting more representative admission standards - though less objective - IITs may be able to get students with potential for creativity and research. This may reduce the importance of coaching factories.

-





Related India Education News
Apex court approves stringent anti-ragging measures
'I want to be guiding light for Muslim girls'
Art attack: UGC asks MSU to clarify
Farmer's son motivated to join civil service after sister's death
Jharkhand teachers threaten boycott of summer classes
Rajasthan to get new private universities act
Sister's death motivated him to take up civil service
No summer vacation for Jharkhand schools this year
NCERT blames states for shortage of books
OBC candidate Revu tops civil services examination

Subscribe to India Education Newsletter
E-mail Address:

 Feedback
For any corrections of factual information, to contact the editors or to send any medical news or health news press releases, use feedback form

Top of Page

 
© All rights reserved 2004 onwards by RxPG Medical Solutions Private Limited
Contact Us