XML Feed for RxPG News   Add RxPG News Headlines to My Yahoo!   Javascript Syndication for RxPG News

Research Health World General
 
  Home
 
   Health
 Aging
 Asian Health
 Events
 Fitness
 Food & Nutrition
 Happiness
 Men's Health
 Mental Health
 Occupational Health
 Parenting
 Public Health
 Sleep Hygiene
 Women's Health
 
   Healthcare
 Africa
 Australia
 Canada Healthcare
 China Healthcare
 India Healthcare
 New Zealand
 South Africa
 UK
 USA
 World Healthcare
 
   Latest Research
 Aging
 Alternative Medicine
 Anaethesia
 Biochemistry
 Biotechnology
 Cancer
 Cardiology
 Clinical Trials
 Cytology
 Dental
 Dermatology
 Embryology
 Endocrinology
 ENT
 Environment
 Epidemiology
 Gastroenterology
 Genetics
 Gynaecology
 Haematology
 Immunology
 Infectious Diseases
 Medicine
 Metabolism
 Microbiology
 Musculoskeletal
 Nephrology
 Neurosciences
 Obstetrics
 Ophthalmology
 Orthopedics
 Paediatrics
 Pathology
 Pharmacology
 Physiology
 Physiotherapy
 Psychiatry
 Radiology
 Rheumatology
 Sports Medicine
 Surgery
 Toxicology
 Urology
 
   Medical News
 Awards & Prizes
 Epidemics
 Launch
 Opinion
 Professionals
 
   Special Topics
 Ethics
 Euthanasia
 Evolution
 Feature
 Odd Medical News
 Climate
Search

Last Updated: Nov 18, 2006 - 1:55:25 PM
Editorial
British Medical Journal

Ethics Channel
subscribe to Ethics newsletter

Special Topics : Ethics

   DISCUSS   |   EMAIL   |   PRINT
Facial Transplants - Are they justified?
Dec 12, 2005 - 4:08:00 PM, Reviewed by: Dr. Priya Saxena

�Indeed, preoccupation with altered identity risks becoming too much of a distraction from the important issue of managing immunosuppression. But, instead of considering why facial transplantation cannot be justified, we may find it hard to justify why it should not be done,�

 
With news of the world�s first facial transplant hitting the headlines, experts in this week�s BMJ debate whether the benefit of this procedure to someone with severe facial deformity outweighs the risk of long term suppression of the immune system.

One of the main areas of concern has been the risk to patients from the side effects of long term immunosuppression, say the authors. However, a patient having a facial transplant would probably require a similar level of immunosuppression to patient having a kidney transplant.

Given that one of the main justifications for kidney transplantation is improvement in quality of life, the same argument should apply to facial transplant, they write.

Concern over psychological effects is also misplaced, they say. They argue that a psychological change is not necessarily a psychological problem, and believe that the psychological impact of facial transplant can be anticipated, planned for and managed.

Facial Transplants - Are they justified?
BMJ 2005;331:1349-1350 (10 December)


In terms of public fears over altered identity, the authors explain that modelling of the change in appearance, using laser scanning and photography, shows that this does not occur after facial transplantation. �Indeed, preoccupation with altered identity risks becoming too much of a distraction from the important issue of managing immunosuppression,� they warn.

Although research has made the concept of facial transplant a reality, concerns about long term immunosuppression do remain. �But, instead of considering why facial transplantation cannot be justified, we may find it hard to justify why it should not be done,� they conclude.
 

- British Medical Journal 10 December 2005 (Vol 331, No 7529)
 

Read the full text of the editorial at bmj.com (Editorial: Facial transplantation, BMJ)

 
Subscribe to Ethics Newsletter
E-mail Address:

 



Related Ethics News
Regulating stem cell research
Overcoming Ethical Constraints
Drug tests on animals may be unreliable: study
Waiting For Trial Results Sometimes Unethical
NHGRI Funds Assessment of Public Attitudes About Population-Based Studies on Genes and Environment
Physicians More Likely To Disclose Medical Errors That Would Be Apparent To The Patient
Doctors inadvertently help terminally ill patients to die sooner
Intellectual property law and the protection of traditional knowledge
Conscientious objection in medicine should not be tolerated
Yale guidelines for physician interactions with pharmaceutical industry


For any corrections of factual information, to contact the editors or to send any medical news or health news press releases, use feedback form

Top of Page

 

© Copyright 2004 onwards by RxPG Medical Solutions Private Limited
Contact Us