RxPG News Feed for RxPG News

Medical Research Health Special Topics World
  Home
 
   Health
 Aging
 Asian Health
 Events
 Fitness
 Food & Nutrition
 Happiness
 Men's Health
 Mental Health
 Occupational Health
 Parenting
 Public Health
 Sleep Hygiene
 Women's Health
 
   Healthcare
 Africa
 Australia
 Canada Healthcare
 China Healthcare
 India Healthcare
 New Zealand
 South Africa
 UK
  NHS
 USA
 World Healthcare
 
   Latest Research
 Aging
 Alternative Medicine
 Anaethesia
 Biochemistry
 Biotechnology
 Cancer
 Cardiology
 Clinical Trials
 Cytology
 Dental
 Dermatology
 Embryology
 Endocrinology
 ENT
 Environment
 Epidemiology
 Gastroenterology
 Genetics
 Gynaecology
 Haematology
 Immunology
 Infectious Diseases
 Medicine
 Metabolism
 Microbiology
 Musculoskeletal
 Nephrology
 Neurosciences
 Obstetrics
 Ophthalmology
 Orthopedics
 Paediatrics
 Pathology
 Pharmacology
 Physiology
 Physiotherapy
 Psychiatry
 Radiology
 Rheumatology
 Sports Medicine
 Surgery
 Toxicology
 Urology
 
   Medical News
 Awards & Prizes
 Epidemics
 Launch
 Opinion
 Professionals
 
   Special Topics
 Ethics
 Euthanasia
 Evolution
 Feature
 Odd Medical News
 Climate

Last Updated: Oct 11, 2012 - 10:22:56 PM
NHS Channel

subscribe to NHS newsletter
Healthcare : UK : NHS

   EMAIL   |   PRINT
Is doctors' pay responsible for the financial crisis in the NHS ?

Feb 5, 2007 - 12:54:37 PM , Reviewed by: Dr. Rashmi Yadav

Key Points of this article
Professor Maynard argues that the consultant contract and the cost of replacing out-of-hours cover with other providers have also increased expenditure.
He writes that, this pay increase has inflated NHS expenditure with all too little benefit to patients.
The government claims that general practitioners' pay has risen unexpectedly, but this is not so.
Total pay has been deliberately misquoted by adding the employers' pension contribution.
 
[RxPG] Recent newspaper headlines have suggested that doctors' pay is responsible for the financial crisis in the NHS. In this week's BMJ, two experts go head to head over whether the remuneration is justified.

Alan Maynard, Professor of Health Economics at York University argues that doctors' self interest manifests itself in two ways: enhancing personal income and protecting clinical autonomy fiercely - the right to do what they think is best for their patients.

He maintains that the first type of self interest has enhanced average UK earnings to over £100,000 for both general practitioners and consultants, with little observable improved activity or patient outcomes.

The general practice quality and outcomes framework raised earnings, but, he argues, with a limited evidence base and little baseline data its benefits are uncertain. The consultant contract and the cost of replacing out-of-hours cover with other providers have also increased expenditure.

Professor Maynard writes that this pay increase has inflated NHS expenditure with all too little benefit to patients or taxpayers, while giving more general practitioners incentives to deliver what good practitioners were already providing.

The second area of doctors' self interest is the understandable desire to do the best for their patients. But he believes that this can lead to inefficient practice that ignores the opportunity costs of decision making. For example, a decision to give Jones a marginally cost effective treatment deprives Smith of cost effective care. Such inefficiency in the use of society's scarce resources is surely unethical, he asks?

These pay increases, together with workforce management which has led to unaffordable employment increases, are creating deficits and undermining patient care and the financial performance of the NHS, he argues. Instead of talking simply about money, we need to determine whether its use benefits patients or is merely a form of social security for providers.

But Laurence Buckman, a GP in London believes that demanding and receiving proper pay and conditions is everyone's right, even in the public sector. This is not self interest. Self interested doctors would go and work elsewhere, he writes.

Until 2003, general practitioners were working long hours, including nights and weekends, and out of hours pay was low. The new contract was an attempt to correct that by placing contracts with practices rather than general practitioners, setting limits to what a practice could be asked to do, and creating a total budget for staff and expenses. General practitioners' pay became the profit that was left after expenses.

The main source of extra income into practices from the new contract is the quality and outcomes framework, which accounts for 40% of practice income. The government claims that general practitioners' pay has risen unexpectedly, but this is not so. The BMA predicted the rise quite accurately, he says.

Total pay has been deliberately misquoted by adding the employers' pension contribution that general practitioners have to pay for themselves – which makes pay seem 14% higher than it is.

Government figures show a shortage of general practitioners. If self interest had been pandered to there would be a glut of doctors. That there isn't is because of the dreadful way that the NHS is managed by a government bereft of ideas and the honesty and wit to tackle the problems that deter young people from joining us, he argues.

Doctors are fed up with being told that the small percentage of the NHS that they cost is the reason why the NHS is in financial trouble. Most patients see us as part of the solution and are willing to pay.



Publication: BMJ 
On the web: http://www.bmj.com/ 

Advertise in this space for $10 per month. Contact us today.


Related NHS News
Systematic bias in the assessment of UK doctors
Depression is wrongly seen as natural part of getting older
NRI doctor guilty of unethical tests on British patients
New steps to curb overseas doctors in Britain
Should EU patient information laws be relaxed?
Institutional discrimination by NHS causing unnecessary deaths of people with a learning disability
Should the NHS curb spending on translation services?
The NHS Redress Act may lead to more complaints
Patients should cc the benefits of doctors' letters
Is doctors' pay responsible for the financial crisis in the NHS ?

Subscribe to NHS Newsletter

Enter your email address:


 About Dr. Rashmi Yadav
This news story has been reviewed by Dr. Rashmi Yadav before its publication on RxPG News website. Dr. Rashmi Yadav, MBBS, is a senior editor for RxPG News. In her position she is responsible for managing special correspondents and the surgery section of the website. Her areas of special interest include cardiothoracic surgery and interventional radiology.
RxPG News is committed to promotion and implementation of Evidence Based Medical Journalism in all channels of mass media including internet.
 Feedback
For any corrections of factual information, to contact the editors or to send any medical news or health news press releases, use feedback form

Top of Page

 
Contact us

RxPG Online

Nerve

 

    Full Text RSS

© All rights reserved by RxPG Medical Solutions Private Limited (India)